The Final Trick
Introduction: Some crime stories you read they stick with you in a bad way. You keep aching for the victims and you keep wishing the perpetrators got a better justice than they did. Even sometimes when it was the death penalty they eventually got. And much Much too often certain things you cross paths with in your day suddenly remind you of those crimes and you just start feeling that ache all over again. The human brain was probably not made to absorb so much bad stuff as we can now in the twenty-first century.
I suppose a shrink could help me figure it out, but I’ve always had my art to rely on when it gets too much. I am mostly a graphic artist…I paint, I draw, I make photography. But I also write. I daydream a lot, maybe way too much, and every now and then I’m able to hammer my daydreams into something like a story. This is one, and it’s about a crime I cannot get completely out of my head, so I decided to give it my own ending…something I thought better fitting to the crime.
This is pretty much a horror story, and I’m a bit surprised it came out of me the way it does because I am Not into grisly sorts of horror stories. So if those sorts of stories put you off, then don’t bother with this one. I understand completely.
It probably won’t be very difficult at all to figure out which crime it is I’m reworking here, and if that disturbs anyone related to the actual victims of this man I am sorry. Also, if this creeps you out in a way you never expected to be creeped out about Bruce, I am sorry about that too. But I needed my own form of closure. Some crimes really bother me too much. This was one of them. There are others.
The Final Trick
by Bruce Garrett
No bright light announced his arrival, no strange unearthly sounds. Only a slight deepening of shadow in one area of the alleyway, as if the light that settled there was abruptly siphoned off to elsewhere. That, and a soft noise like the opening and closing of a far away door.
From the darkness a figure walked forward. Slight, graceful, with purpose. A teenage boy, though at first glance he might have been mistaken for a young girl. His hair was long and blond. It cascaded around the face of an angel. He stopped. With a pair of darkly alert eyes he scanned his immediate surroundings. He wore only a closely fitting white t-shirt, a pair of very short cutoff blue jeans, white socks, and tennis shoes of a brand popular with local teenage boys. A small backpack was slung over his shoulders. An inexpensive dime store watch was strapped to his left wrist.
His eyes fixed on a few items in the alleyway. A small cluster of metal trash cans huddled nearby. Further away some battered boxes, crates and random litter. He walked over to the crates and for a moment studied the labels on them. Then he carefully turned them over, noting how the wooden pieces joined together. He seemed fascinated. Then he put them down, stepped back, and looked up at the city skyline overhead.
It was long past midnight on a hot humid big city summer day in 1978. There was no moon. The heat and humidity made the air hazy, ever so delicately blurring the outlines of skyscrapers in the distance. For a moment the youth stood absolutely still, his eyes darting here and there, as though seeing his surroundings for the first time, with eyes that had seen it many times.
He glanced at his watch, nodded, and strode toward the street at the end of the alley.
Soon now…
He emerged to a hushed and darkened street empty of traffic. This was not the busy part of town, at least not at this time of night. Windowless brick and concrete block walls crowded up against both sides of the street where he stood; warehouses silently waiting for the morning shift. Light came from a bus terminal a short distance away. It seemed almost deserted. There was a parked car on the other side of the street which he studied, then with his eyes discarded. Further down was a dimly lit phone booth. He paused, seemed to consider walking toward it, then looked at the watch again.
He stepped up to the sidewalk on his left, positioned himself next to the curb, and began watching the darkness further down the street.
The minutes passed. A car drove past. Then another. A battered pickup truck pulled up briefly near the bus stop, took on a passenger, and drove away. For a while it was quiet again. Then a sleek white sports car appeared out of the darkness, low to the ground, rumbling from its powerful engine and illegal tailpipes. The youth studied it briefly, looked away, and stepped back from the curb.
Not you…
But the car pulled up to the sidewalk where he stood, and a window rolled down. Inside was a man of perhaps 50, hair neatly combed, dressed casually, looking intently at the youth. The faint scent of very expensive men’s cologne and money came from inside the car.
This must be my lucky night…can’t be more than fourteen…
“Hey kid,” said the man, “Need a ride somewhere?”
The boy came forward, bent down to the passenger side window.
Good god he’s beautiful…nice legs…
The boy gave the man a radiant smile. Something about his eyes was wrong. There were depths of darkness in them, and they appeared much older than the face. When he began to speak, it was in a voice that sounded decades older than it should have.
“Mr. Baylor, don’t you think it’s about time you told your wife Ellen that you’re homosexual? Chasing after runaway teenage boys at the south side bus stop is no way for an airline executive to spend his life. Get yourself out of that damn closet. Be proud. Find a good man.”
The car squealed rubber leaving the scene. The boy watched it go, then resumed watching the other direction.
Soon another car appeared in the darkness. A large Detroit sedan, painted a dark blue, drove up to the curb.
Ah…yes…
The passenger side window rolled down. Behind the wheel was a middle aged man of perhaps forty. His face was round and his eyes small. A weak chin poked tentatively out, but there was almost no jaw line to speak of. Sweat glistened slightly over a pronounced five o-clock shadow. His stomach rested against the bottom of the steering wheel. He was wearing an evening suit with no tie, and the shirt collar open. He looked at the boy with a hunger just barely concealed by the friendly smile he wore.
“Hey kid…looking for a ride somewhere”?
“No sir. My uncle’s going to pick me up in a few…” He spoke with the voice of a teenage boy of fourteen or thereabouts. The accent was local. The man figured him for a Roger’s Park kid. His interest grew.
“This isn’t a very safe part of town kid. Guy your age shouldn’t be out alone here at night. I can take you somewhere.”
“Thanks mister but I’m okay.” The boy shrugged and looked sadly around. “If there’s anything I need it’s a job somewhere else. Dad sent me here to go work for my uncle this summer. He’ll be here soon.”
“What’s your uncle do?”
The teenager shrugged again. “Boring stuff mostly.”
The man’s expression changed. Now it was a look of fatherly concern. “Well what would you like to do kid?”
“I’m pretty good at woodworking if I have the right tools. I’ve been helping mom and dad remodel the house. It’s actually kinda fun.”
The man smiled. “Well you’re in luck kid. I do contracting work of all kinds. If you have some time I’ll take you to my place and show you some of what I have going on. Maybe I can sign you up. I’ve got a big job starting tomorrow and I need some extra hands. It won’t take long.”
The boy looked away. “I don’t know…my uncle will be expecting me to be here…”
“I pay five dollars an hour to start.”
“Wow!” The youth glanced at his wristwatch. “Well, but I’d better be back here in an hour”.
“No problem. Get in. This could be your lucky day.”
The boy grinned happily. He took off his backpack, opened the passenger door and sat down with it between his feet. Then he reached out and closed the door. The car drove off.
“What’s your name kid?”
“Seth.”
“Mine’s John. Where are you from?”
“Oh…here originally. Mom and Dad moved to Iowa when dad got a better job. But it’s boring. I like coming back to visit here, even if I have to go work for uncle Max. I still have some friends here. We hang out.”
“I hear that about Iowa. I lived there myself for a while.” The man shook his head ruefully. “I’ll never go back.”
He glanced again at the youth who gave him a radiant smile. My God this one’s a beauty. The man drew his breath, turned his eyes back to the road. Eventually he said “You got a nice smile there kid. My customers will love you.”
The youth looked away and smiled again, softly, to himself.
The trick is having the key…
“This is a good town.” the man said. “I do a lot of business here.” He glanced at the backpack on the floor. “You got your things in there?”
“Some. And a few books to read on the bus.”
“Oh? What do you like reading?”
“Science-fiction mostly.”
“You like those outer space adventures do you?”
“They’re about time travel. It’s interesting.”
“Huh. Boy if I could go back in time…” the man began, then his voice trailed off.
“What?”
“I’d do some things differently.” He sighed. “But no sense living in the past.”
“The youth nodded. “You have to be careful. Even changing something small can undo the future you came from. Ray Bradbury wrote a story once about a man who went dinosaur hunting and accidentally killed a butterfly, and when he got back to his time everything was different. Bad. Really bad.”
The man chuckled. It was a generous good natured sound.“Sure, but what if you went back in time and killed Hitler though. That would keep Germany from going down the tubes, right? Then the war never happens and Poland and all those others would still be free countries.”
“Everyone wants to go back in time and kill Hitler. But maybe then someone even worse than Hitler comes to power, and then the whole world falls to the Nazis.” The boy looked down and for a moment seemed genuinely sad. Then he said more solemnly, as though repeating an oath, “You must be careful what you do…”
“Heh, yeah, but say…all that science-fiction stuff is just for kids….” the man glanced at the youth, gave him a perfectly charming smile. “But then you’re a kid aren’t you. So it’s okay huh.”
The boy returned the man’s smile. “You’re the guy who does the clown act aren’t you?”
The man looked ahead, startled. “You know me?”
“I recognise you now. You came to my school once. Everyone loved your tricks. I wish there were more people like you that just want to make everyone laugh. I bet you’re a great guy to work for.”
The man smiled, kept his eyes on the road ahead. You can really lay it on thick for five bucks an hour can’t you boy… “Hey thanks kid. I’ll show you some clown tricks when we get to my place”
The boy settled back in his seat, put his hands behind his head, and stretched languidly. For an instant the man caught a glimpse of bare stomach, and a small bit of white underwear elastic showing above the beltline.
“I’d like that,” he said. “Very much.”
The car pulled up to a garage next to a house in a suburban tract neighborhood where every house looked like every other house. The man got out, saw the boy looking around intently, with fascination, at the house, at the neighborhood, like he’d never seen anything like it before.
Live all your life in the city did you kid…?
“Just leave your backpack in the car. We won’t be long. Gotta get you back to your uncle before he starts worrying.”
The boy nodded amicably, a lock of golden hair falling across one eye. He walked ahead of the man to a side door. Something about the deliberate way he moved his hips as he walked finally aroused the man’s suspicions.
This kid…was he really looking for a job…or is he cruising..? Is he really as young as he says?
His eyes narrowed. Those shorts…that’s a working boy. I’ve seen his type before. Face like that lets them get away with murder. He might be twenty. Looking for old guys he thinks he can rob or blackmail. Well…so much the better. They won’t be looking for him…nobody cares about a prostitute from the poor side of town…
He looked at the ass in front of him a bit more closely. It was the nicest ass he’d ever seen on a male. The way it moved when the kid walked shot a thrill through him. Between enchantment and a deeply felt resentment never far from the surface, the man thought to himself, He knows he can get away with anything with an ass like that… Then came thoughts of what was to happen soon and his groin began to stiffen. Sex was tame compared to murder.
There was a time when he couldn’t get enough sex. Teenagers were the best, their skin was so smooth, their buns so hard. And the terrified look in their eyes when they realized it was too late was the best part. No adult could express fear so completely as a child. A twenty-ish something would do, but a trembling crying terrified teenager was the best.
Once, sex was all there was to it; but that was long ago, or so it seemed now. The intense orgasm he experienced the first time he killed one of his tricks, an accident, he hadn’t meant to, was a revelation that ushered him into a new world of pleasure. He was almost completely disinterested in the sex act itself now. Sex was just another instrument of torture, another way to inflict pain and terrorize before the final magic trick. Murder was the ultimate thrill.
He studied his prey carefully. He always did. He was good at it. Maybe the best that ever was. He had a body count to prove it.
I can see a wallet bulge there in the right pocket…nothing else. He can’t possibly have any weapons on him wearing that. Not even a switchblade. Good…
They went inside. The man flipped on a light, saw the boy looking around as if in a museum. He touched one of the pine wall panels almost reverently. Then he noticed the man watching him. “Nice place mister.” He pointed at a painting of a clown on the opposite wall. “That you?”
“Na. It’s just something a friend gave me. Nice though. Here, come with me…I want to show you something. You remembered my clown act. Let me show you where the magic begins.”
The boy followed him down a narrow hallway, to a room in the back. It was sparsely furnished, like a largely unused guest room, though it had been carefully cleaned recently. A single chair and a wooden chest of drawers sat against the wall at one end. A footlocker rested against the bottom of a small iron framed guest bed set against the opposite wall. The boy studied the iron rails of the headboard, then looked over at the chair. The man walked over to the chest of drawers and pulled the top one open.
“Here’s where I keep my magic tricks and makeup…”
For the next half hour the man regaled the teenager with various clown tricks and gags. He told jokes, did a little dance after each magic trick, carefully showing the boy how each of them worked at the end. The teenager applauded after each one delightedly and said, “You’re amazing. I would never have guessed how that worked.”
From the top drawer the man pulled out a pair of chrome plated handcuffs. “Now I want to show you my favorite trick. I call it the handcuff trick.” He held the handcuffs out to the youth. “It’s a killer. Here…put these on me.”
The youth took the handcuffs from the man carefully, as though handling an artifact of great significance.
So these are…the very ones…
The man put his hands behind his back. “Put them on as tight as you like.”
Grinning happily, the youth complied. The man turned around, smiled, then brought his hands back around, with the handcuffs dangling from the finger of one hand.
“Wow…how’d you do that?”
“I’ll show you. Put them on.”
The youth gave him a delighted smile. “Okay…but first I have to tell you a joke.”
It wasn’t in the script, but the man was agreeable. “A joke about handcuffs?”
“Just a joke. You’ll love it. One day a teenage boy was hitch-hiking. He’s young, he’s sexy…” the youth tossed his hair and shook his hips. ”…and he’s hitch-hiking long after midnight, on a dark and deserted street all by himself. All by himself! Can’t you just picture it?”
The man grew vaguely suspicious but kept smiling pleasantly. He was not alarmed. Whatever he’s got planned I can take him easily…
“Then a car comes along and stops. A man inside asks him if he wants a ride. And the kid says yes, thanks mister, and he gets in.”
The man nodded, his eyes expressionless.
“So they’re driving down this dark and lonely road. You gotta picture this. The kid’s all alone with this man who picked him up. There’s nobody else for miles around. And the man leans over to the boy and says,” the boy imitated a low throaty male voice, “‘aren’t you afraid of being picked up by a serial killer?’”
A pause. “Go on…” said the man slowly.
The youth in front of him was almost dancing with glee. “And the punchline is…oh this is just hilarious…the punchline is the kid says ‘Oh no sir. The odds of two serial killers being in the same car at the same time are just astronomical!’”
There was a moment’s silence. The boy smiled broadly, his eyes sparkled with delight. “Get it?”
Some feral instinct made the man lunge forward. Stupid little punk… It was his last coherent thought. In the next instant the air in front of him exploded in fire and light and a sound of thunder. There was an impact, like being kicked in the head by a horse. He staggered back.
The derringer appeared in the boy’s hand as if out of thin air. It was flat, shaped like a wallet, with two barrels and a hole for a trigger, which he pulled again. There was a flash of light and fire and dozens of tiny lead balls tore through the man’s head at nearly the speed of sound. He staggered and fell, blood gushing from dozens of tiny pinpoint wounds.
Calmly, still grinning delightedly, the boy tipped forward the barrels of the derringer, and extracted two empty 22 rimfire magnum shotshell casings, which he placed into his right pocket. From his left he extracted two more cartridges with copper plated hollow nose bullets. These he slid into the derringer, and locked the barrels back into place.
He knelt down to the man’s head, beautiful eyes alive with an orgasmic pleasure. But first, a final dispensing of pain. Sensual lips parted. An old man’s voice spoke.
“Your father was right about you. But you know that. They will find all the bodies. Everyone will know what you are, and what you did.” A pause. Then, “Do you believe in Hell?”
A wet gurgle escaped the man’s throat. The boy leaned back, sighed softly in ecstasy, placed the derringer to the man’s head, and fired again. Twice.
Days later, after his friends reported him missing, the police entered the man’s house and found his body. On it was pinned a note, detailing where the bodies of 16 young men were to be found, each with a name and contact information for their relatives.
A nation was properly horrified. A search commenced for the man’s killer. Some wanted to reward him. Some hoped he was never found.
In the decades to follow theories would be offered to explain what had happened that night. Most held there was an accomplice who had helped dig the graves and got into a final, fatal argument with the man and shot him. A popular competing theory was the man had picked up a trick for the night who turned out to be another serial killer like himself, targeting older homosexual men who preyed on boys. The killer trick had found the note among the man’s trophies and simply pinned it on him. The disciples of this theory would all agree the two killers were made for each other.
Driver’s licenses, random personal belongings and jewelry from the man’s young victims were discovered in one of the drawers next to his magic tricks. Neither the accomplice, if there was one, nor the killer trick if he existed, were ever found. The note was dusted for fingerprints but none were found. Eventually the note would be given to the FBI forensics lab, which would puzzle over it for decades, wondering where the uncanny artificial fiber based paper was manufactured, and what strange printer had been used to print it. Decades later it would be lost due to a bureaucratic error.
The bodies were all found, grieving families notified, victims finally given a decent burial, and the people of the city suitably shocked that such a respectable man could have done such an evil thing for so long without anyone noticing. The media spotlight would soon go elsewhere. Pinning the identity of the man’s killer on other known serial murderers, former Nazi war criminals in hiding, mafia hitmen, shadowy government agencies, time travelers, and space aliens would become a staple of cable TV unsolved mystery shows and the pages of paperback books and tabloid magazines sold in airports and bus stations.
The TV cameras circled around the man’s house, the reporters gathered, and the gawkers stood watching the bodies being removed, as if at a circus act gone terribly wrong. No one noticed the slender old man at the fringes, watching carefully with dark captivated eyes.
Yes, the old man thought, he was right about one thing: murder was the ultimate thrill. However it could cause chaos, heartbreak and dangerous social instability if not properly managed. And he was being very properly managed. He was actually grateful for that. The dangerous passions of a few had to be carefully managed, and if some innocent lives could be saved in the process so much the better. But first more simulations would have to be run. Let’s not be killing any butterflies shall we.
He turned away from the scene, and began walking down the street, away from the crowds, old, slight, graceful, and with purpose, to some elsewhere only he could see, eyes shining in anticipation. There was a faint sound of a far away door opening and closing. Nobody noticed he was gone.
Posted In: Fiction
Tags: Staring Into The Abyss But With Art!













































