Deep Thought Of The Day…
If there are no Atheists in foxholes, then there are probably no believers in Dumpsville either.
Posted In: Uncategorized
Tags: The Dumpsville Chronicles
![]() The Cartoon Gallery A Coming Out Story
New and Improved!
The Story So Far archives My Amazon.Com Wish List My Myspace Profile Bruce Garrett's Profile ![]() ![]() Alicublog Wayne Besen Beyond Ex-Gay (A Survivor's Community) Box Turtle Bulletin Chrome Tuna Daily Kos Mike Daisy's Blog The Disney Blog Disney Dorks Envisioning The American Dream Eschaton Ex-Gay Watch Hullabaloo Joe. My. God Peterson Toscano Progress City USA Slacktivist SLOG ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() The Rittenhouse Review Steve Gilliard's News Blog Steve Gilliard's Blogspot Site ![]() ![]() Tripping Over You ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Bors Blog John K Penny Arcade ![]() Lead Stories Amtrak In The Heartland Corridor Capital Railway Age Maryland Weather Blog Foot's Forecast ![]() Baltimore Crime ![]() HinesSight Page One Q (GLBT News) Michelangelo Signorile ![]() Talking Points Memo Truth Wins Out The Raw Story Slashdot ![]() BBC NIS News Bulletin (Dutch) Mexico Daily The Local (Sweden) ![]() ![]() The Local Deutsche Welle Young Germany ![]() ![]() Plan 59 Pleasant Family Shopping Discount Stores of the 60s Retrospace Photos of the Forgotten Boom-Pop! Comics With Problems HMK Mystery Streams ![]() Mercedes-Benz USA Mercedes-Benz TV Mercedes-Benz Owners Club of America MBCA - Greater Washington Section BenzInsider Mercedes-Benz Blog BenzWorld Forum |
February 1st, 2009 Deep Thought Of The Day… If there are no Atheists in foxholes, then there are probably no believers in Dumpsville either.
About Right… Via Sullivan…
He called it a poem for Sunday. I’d say it makes a good Valentine’s Day poem. Or an any day poem at this stage of my life. Being as I am, at that age where death isn’t totally unexpected… "I thought he died a while ago…" I hate this time of year. Not only is it dark and cold and covered with ice, la, la, la, la, la…it’s that Most Romantic Day Of The Year! !!! Er…wait a minute… Maybe there’s a connection…
Not Dead Yet… …Just really preoccupied with the house. On Wednesday I discovered that a leak in the roof, near the back of the house by the chimney, that I thought had been taken care of was back with a vengeance. Between that and other more routine maintenance here at Casa del Garrett I’ve been away from the den computer more then usual. And…I really don’t feel talkative right now…for some reason…
January 28th, 2009 The Party Of Culture War Sullivan notices the obvious…
The republicans became the party of culture war when they gave the nomination to Nixon. This is what people continue not to get about them…even now, amidst the horrific train wreckage of the "free market economy" republican domination of the federal government was supposed to usher in. Oh…they betrayed their principles, did you say? No. Absolutely no. They did nothing of the kind. All that small government free market stuff was just the window dressing, over a core that was entirely, completely, absolutely about culture war. When they finally got the power they craved, they set to work implementing their vision. Yes, it is an unmitigated disaster. But you have to understand that it was always going to be that. They didn’t care about the economy…they cared about elbowing science out of the classroom and out of government in favor of their nutty religion in which Jesus says to hate the stranger, obey the authorities, and that the rich will inherent the earth. They didn’t care about the deficit…they cared about keeping women, people of color and homosexuals in their place. They didn’t care about national security…they cared about rolling back decades of constitutional law that said all Americans were entitled to equal justice, equal rights, to life, liberty, and the persuit of happiness. They didn’t care about fighting terrorism…they cared about fighting the 60s all over again, and winning this time. In Goldwater they had their last honest small government candidate. Nixon gave them culture war, which they embraced with gusto. Why? The darkies weren’t drinking from the fountain marked ‘coloreds’ anymore. The kids weren’t passively going off to die in a war nobody understood, and what was worse, they weren’t cutting their hair. And more horrifying then all of that, the women were going off the Miltown pill and going on the birth control one instead and asserting their sexual equality. Suddenly you couldn’t make jokes about women drivers anymore. And then the faggots started marching. Something had to be done. Nixon was the one. That he turned out to be a crook, should have been a warning. But the first thing you have to understand about culture warriors, is they have no inner sense of morality, of right and wrong. That is why they fight tooth and nail to keep their world from changing around them. They have no brakes, so they need fences and guardrails. That, and the privilege that comes with being on top of the cultural ladder, even if you’re at the bottom of the economic one. White. Male. Protestant. Heterosexual. You got it made pal…drink up. In a world where people are judged by the content of their character, not the color of their skin, or the shape of their own genitals or that of their lovers’, then what becomes of the privileged? The joke after the last Republican convention was that you didn’t see any black or brown faces in the crowd until it was all over, and the cleaning crews came out. So what about all that Big Tent talk? What about all that reaching out to minorities and stuff? For real? Why…the same Goddamned thing that happened to all that small government stuff. It wasn’t important. It wasn’t what the party is about. The party is about the culture war. Of course the first thing they had fits about in the stimulus plan was the family planning items. Do you still think, after the last eight years of it, that they even saw the rest of it? I sure hope you don’t think that since Bush went down in flames they went down with him. They sure didn’t go down with Nixon.
Jealous…Me…? So…I’m wandering the web and the various gay news sites and I come across this shot of actor TR Knight and his BF doing Disneyland…
More Here. I recall wandering around Disneyworld not too long ago. I had a great time. But I go into these vacations willing myself not to think about how alone I am wherever I go…which is one reason I’ve always avoided theme parks. If I don’t do that, if I’m not successful at forgetting, then I just want to go back home. And there have been times I’ve done just that. I’m happy for these guys. I really am. But seeing stuff like this…at this stage of my life…just reminds me of the life I never had and I don’t want it to. I just want to feel happy for them. But…I failed. I never found it. God knows I tried (even if a certain heartless jackass in Alexandria wants to keep telling himself that I never did). I tried. It never happened. It just…never happened. But then…people who look like that want people who look like that… Wow… That looks like the Big Thunder Mountain Railroad ride. I wanted to do that one while I was at Disneyworld but I thought, one roller coaster at a time so I did Space Mountain instead. Look at those smiles. Damn. Just…Damn…
The Mormon War On Gay Americans Timothy Kincaid over at Box Turtle Bulletin, has the party line vote on the first of the so-called "common ground" bills put forward in Utah. These bills actually do very little to insure equal rights for gay and lesbian citizens…almost the bare minimum you could imagine. The first of these to come to a vote, simply made it possible for financial dependents, other then legally married spouses, parents and children, to sue if their breadwinner suffers wrongful death. Keep in mind that these so-called "common ground" bills were introduced after the passage of Proposition 8, when the Mormon church’s staggering level of involvement became widely known, and the Mormon leadership, while in the glare of the public eye, averred they had no problem with extending gay people many of the rights of marriage…just not marriage itself. Many of us found that statement interesting, since nothing was stopping them from giving gay Americans in Utah those rights and gay Americans in Utah have damn few if any. The only places as bad to be gay are the deep south The bill failed along party lines. Republican verses democrat? Oh my, no…
As Kincaid notes, this fits pretty well with recent polls showing that Utah Mormons are hugely against granting their gay neighbors any rights whatsoever, other then maybe, possibly, the right to breath. So long as they don’t flaunt it. Expect the Mormon church to claim it has no influence over the state legislature. They’ve shown repeatedly that they can look you right in the eye, smile, and lie through their teeth. Your hopes, your dreams, every smile you ever gave the one you love, and every smile you ever received in love, and placed somewhere deep within your heart: these things are their stepping stones to Godhood. Nothing else matters to them. Nothing. They will walk over your every hope and dream, and grind them into dirt, for that promise of Godhood at the end of the road. I know…I know… But there are Mormons who don’t hate their gay neighbor… Yes. And they are either silent or they are on the road to excommunication. We, that is America, saw it all during the battle over Proposition 8. There are no Mormons who are not on board for the war on gay Americans…only Mormons who are about to leave, or be shown the door.
Always Respect Ice I’ve said before I’d rather have two feet of snow then even a little ice. Snow you can at least dig out of. Snow at least makes it clear that your car isn’t going anywhere. And you know you are going to be in for a trudge when you walk through it, and that you need to watch where you put your feet. Ice just sits there and pretends to be a little wet patch on the sidewalk ahead of you. And if the temperature is just right, it coats itself with a film of water on its surface and dares you to walk across it. This morning the sidewalks and streets around my neighborhood were dangerous to even stand on. You just couldn’t. The moment I stepped outside to start cleaning off my sidewalk, I knew I had to be careful. My snow boots give me no traction at all on the pavement. The ice was easy to break up though, because the pavement under it was wet, not frozen. I have an all metal snow shovel I bought ages ago, for digging my car out when the snow plows had buried it. I begin to just bang the shovel down on the ice while standing on the dry portions of my front porch. The ice cracked apart and I could just shovel off the broken chunks. Then I moved forward and bit and repeated the process. Wash, rinse, repeat… I’d got all the way down to my street and I was breaking up the ice on my sidewalk when I head a moan behind me. It was coming from somewhere in the street, but I couldn’t see who it was because of the parked cars. When I tried to walk out onto the street I could tell right away that two feet just weren’t going to cut it so I knelt down. The street was a solid sheet of ice…not very thick…but with a little layer of water on top as the temperature was hovering around the freezing point. I literally had to walk on my hands and knees out into the street. That was when I saw her…an older neighbor of mine laying on her side in the middle of the road. I could see blood around her head from where I was. You have to picture this. There really isn’t very much ice on the road, but it is smooth…almost ice rink smooth. And it has just enough water on its surface that you simply can’t stand on it. Your instinct is to run over to help her and you can’t. You simply cannot stand on the ice. The woman’s daughter was trying to get out to her from the sidewalk just then too, but she wasn’t able to navigate the road any better then me. She’s telling her mom not to move and I’m telling them both I’m coming and nobody is getting there any time soon. I had to literally walk on my hands and knees to get out to her, but eventually I did. Luckily, oh so very luckily, our street is a small side street that dead ends, sort-of (there is an alleyway access driveway at the end of it). So there was no traffic trying to get down our street. Not that anyone could have anyway without sliding into something. But that was what I was afraid of right then…some idiot trying to drive down our street, seeing us, hitting the brakes…and well… This particular neighbor is an older lady…in her 60s going on 70s I think. She was laying on her side and the ice under her head was bloody. She was talkative when I got to her, and I asked her if she could feel anything broken. She said not, just her head was painful a bit where her glasses, which she said were up on her head when she tried to walk across the street, banged into her ear when she fell. There was blood all over the ice around her head, but she seemed clear headed and knew to just stay put until the ambulance came. I was hoping the injury was better then it looked. I asked her if she could move her toes and fingers and she said she could. The daughter called for an ambulance, but I think everyone knew it wasn’t going to get there quickly. What eventually happened was a fire truck with some EMTs tried to come down our street and almost slid into some parked cars. So they decided to just send the EMTs on foot to the scene. By that time I was worried about her getting hypothermic and so I crawled back to the sidewalk and went back into the house and I got one of my moving pads out and the EMT people moved her onto it so she wasn’t laying on the ice. She was talkative the whole time and could move her limbs and her fingers and toes. It took the Emergency Crew almost an hour to get an ambulance to her because the streets were all so bad. The initial responder, a fire truck so I was told (I never actually saw it) almost slid into some parked cars and couldn’t get turned onto our street. The ambulance eventually had to back slowly down one side street, up an alley, and then drive over the grassy lot at the end of my street to get close enough to where they could bring a stretcher out to her. When the ambulance crew finally arrived with a stretcher they carefully got her onto it. You could tell she was in pain when they moved her. It really doesn’t matter how much ice you get in an ice storm. Even a little amount of ice is dangerous. And all the more so when the air temperature is hovering around freezing because that leaves a little tad of melt on top and then you might was well crawl across it because you are not walking over it unless you’ve got spikes or something. My neighbor apparently thought that since clearing the sidewalks was so easy this morning, the street wasn’t so bad either. She only got halfway across when her legs went out from under her and she fell. And the problem was with the streets like they were no ambulance was getting to her quickly. It’s going to freeze over again tonight, but the rest of the week looks good. First chance I get I am buying some extra-strength sidewalk and pavement de-icer. The box at the end of the street the city provides is a mix of sand and salt this year…I’m guessing because we have no money and they’re trying to make the salt go further…and it’s a solid brick in there. I have to take a pick to it to get enough of the stuff apart to put into a bucket and salt my sidewalk. They say putting out salt eats away at your pavement, and some of my neighbors refuse to do it because of that. But better my sidewalk and steps get eaten by salt then covered in blood.
Ice Morning There is a sheet of ice all over everything outside here in my little Baltimore neighborhood, but not a quarter inch of it. It’s pretty significant though. When I got up, the first thing I did was look outside to check the ice accumulation. I didn’t see much right off the bat…although the sidewalks looked obviously iced over. But the powerlines and tree branches didn’t seem to have any. Usually, when it’s a really bad freezing rain storm, you get the trees looking a bit glossy, almost like they’re encased in snow, but it’s not snow its ice. This morning they just looked wet. Then I put my glasses on. (sigh) I’ve had to wear glasses for distance vision ever since last February, when I was driving to Memphis and noticed that the lettering on the big highway signs was looking a little fuzzy. I can see okay at a distance, but to see small detail I need my glasses now. Once I had them on this morning, the extent of the ice outside was more apparent. I could clearly see the trees were encased in the stuff too. But not a quarter inch of it. I got dressed and went to step outside. My bird feeders had a full load of customers and there was a downy woodpecker on the suet feeder so I waited for it to get done. The woodpeckers are very shy, even the big ones, and will scoot at a shadow. It didn’t stay long and when it flitted off I stepped out. The gold finches all over my thistle feeders scattered but they come right back. Everything outside here is iced over, but only on top. The tree branches aren’t completely encased it in…they’re dry on the bottom side. In some places it’s thicker then others, but I’d say the thickest it is most places is 1/16 inch. That’s still a lot when it comes to ice. More then enough to shut everything down. When I look upstreet, Redfern Avenue looks like an ice rink, I kid you not. But a neighbor, shoveling it off his sidewalk, said everything was wet underneath. He wasn’t having a hard time getting it up off the sidewalk. So the ground here in Baltimore isn’t frozen. That’ll make it go away quicker. Later in the day, they’re calling for rain. The Institute is closed until 10am, and we can take vacation for the rest of the day on "liberal leave"…meaning it’s okay that you didn’t properly schedule it just go ahead and take it. I’ll wait and see what it’s like before I decide.
Snow. Sleet. Freezing Rain. Baltimore Not exactly your foot deep snowfall…but enough to keep Traveler at home…
Doesn’t it look adorable in the snow? Well…I think it does. And I’m here to tell you owning a forty-five thousand dollar automobile does make you think twice about driving it in snow and icy conditions. And tonight they are forecasting a freezing rain. Swell. If I had studded tires (which are illegal in Maryland anyway) I would not move that car. I can walk to two grocery stores and to work, and in really bad weather, the Institute encourages us to either telecommute or take leave. In a really severe situation they will close down the Institute altogether, for the safety of staff. But you have to understand the work we do is in support of space missions that don’t pause for bad weather on earth, and some folks just have to be on call no matter what. If the power goes out due to ice bringing down lines, or trees onto lines though, I doubt I’ll be able to telecommute. It’s sleeting now as I write this. The forecast is for ice accumulation up to a quarter inch in the city. That’s…pretty bad. The city seldom if ever plows or salts the sidestreets (we have no money) but distributes salt boxes all around the neighborhoods, which I’ve never seen done anywhere else. I am responsible for my own patch of sidewalk…all sixteen feet of it…so I shoveled mine and salted it down before bed. I also put out some extra seed for the birds. Hopefully the feeders won’t be so iced up they can’t get to it. If the power goes out tomorrow, because some tree somewhere upgrid from me came down on some lines, I probably won’t be blogging. BGE is usually pretty good about getting the power back on here in the city…but if the ice is widespread it might take a while. Hopefully, once again, it won’t be as bad as the worst case scenerio the forecast is predicting. A quarter inch of ice is a lot. That’ll bring down some tree limbs around here for sure.
January 27th, 2009 Slouching Back Toward The Dark Ages Via Pam’s House Blend… The next time you hear someone in the Catholic Church complaining that proposition 8 supporters are being targeted, laugh in their face…
More from the Bilerico Project blog…
I hope nobody is surprised. When you hear the Proposition 8 supporters talk of civility and mutual respect, laugh in their face.
Boys Will Be Girls And Girls Will Be Boys I hadn’t known this, but the other day on Fark.Com one of the headlines read that January is National Drag History Month. As a gay man who tends to favor somewhat androgynous males, I have to admit that some of these performers just knock me out. That’s not to say I like it when guys dress up as girls, so much as when guys can be sexy and sultry and beautiful. There’s an art to this that I never really appreciated when I was younger, and stereotyped drag as an artifact of gay repression. You can certainly view it that way. But in a more liberated time, you can also view it as a kind of subversive gender-bending art that is beautiful and sexy for its own sake. Some drag performers don’t have it. They just look like guys wearing dresses. But some guys have got it going on. One commenter on Fark said that a boy in a dress is just a boy in a dress. No… Not at all…
…not at all. So… Happy National Drag History Month Mrs Cuba…aka Deanna Lexington. Wish my friends down there hadn’t been such a bunch of jackass knuckle-dragging dickheads and let me have a chance to meet you last year. But if you happen to chance across this post…I have some more photos from that Academy of Washington D.C. Miss Gaye Universe Ball. It was nice to see you get an award. Personally, I thought you should have taken it all.
Why Deemphasizing Marriage Will Never Work In the wake of the passage of Proposition 8, and predictably, you heard the voices from the back bench bellyaching that we were all fighting the wrong fight. Why are we making such a big deal out of marriage they asked, when we still lack basic anti discrimination protections in jobs and housing? Why are we putting so much energy into a fight about same-sex marriage, which most of the country is against anyway, when gay people can still be fired from their jobs, denied housing, denied service in stores and restaurants? Let’s fight for the basics first, they say. Sure. Go right ahead…
Emphasis mine. Here’s why we’re fighting for same-sex marriage. Because every fight we’ve ever waged as a people has been turned into a fight over same-sex marriage by our enemies. Watch it happen again in the fight for these so-called "common ground" gay rights bills in Utah. Just like it’s happened every time since the days of Antia Bryant and Save Our Children in Florida. It’s ironic that the bigots understand our fight better then many of us do. The same logic that says it’s wrong to deny a gay man a job simply because he is a gay man, what do you know, leads in a straight and narrow path to the conclusion that it is also wrong to deny a gay man the right to marry the man he loves, simply because both of them are gay. To concede it in the one case is to concede it in the other. Though our enemies deny that rhetorically, you can see they know it perfectly well by how they turn every fight we engage in, for every meager right that heterosexuals take for granted every day, into a fight over same-sex marriage. Deemphasize same-sex marriage all you want. Our enemies will underline it in neon. The homosexuals aren’t just fighting for the right to hold down a job. The homosexuals aren’t just fighting for equal housing. The homosexuals aren’t just fighting for the right to adopt. The homosexuals aren’t just fighting for safe schools. The homosexuals aren’t just fighting for the right to serve in the military. The homosexuals aren’t just fighting to repeal the sodomy laws. The homosexuals are fighting to make their perversion morally acceptable. They are fighting for the honor and the dignity of their perverted sexual relationships. Yes. Yes we are. That’s the heart of it. Marriage isn’t central to this fight, but it’s damn close. Closer then anything else in civil law. If our sexual relationships are morally and civilly the equal of heterosexuals’ then not only is there no reason to deny us a job, there is no reason to deny us the right to marry. That is why every fight in this struggle, is a fight over same-sex marriage.
Was Sie mit “wir” weiß gesicht? Winnetou and Old Shatterhand ride again…
Some years ago on one of my road trips as I was driving near Bryce Canyon, I noticed every curio shop and trading post I stopped at all had their prices and item tags on everything in the windows, display cases, and on the clothing racks written in German. This kept happening all the way from Bryce Canyon to Monument Valley, where I finally crossed paths with a huge, and I mean Huge, caravan of tour buses, all loaded to the brims with middle aged German tourists. Nice folk…passionately curious about everything around them…pleasant, polite, cameras clicking away. But they spoke not much if any English at all and stayed close to their tour guides…which makes me wonder to this day about the stories I keep hearing about how English is widely understood in Germany. I happen to catch one of them, a pleasant enough German man, taking a snapshot of my car’s license plate. I have the special "Preserve The Bay" plates which you pay extra for, and the money goes into a fund to help clean up the Chesapeake Bay. It’s distinguished from the standard plates by the state waterfowl, the Great Blue Heron. When the German saw me watching him taking a picture of my plates, he became visibly embarrassed and made a gesture toward the car I took to mean he wanted me to know he was just snapping a tourist photo. I smiled back and wished I could tell him the plate was a special edition and the facts behind it, but all we could do was smile at each across the language barrier. I’ve tried to read Karl May. I can’t. To an American boy who grew up reading Louis L’amour, May is simply unreadable, and I don’t think it’s because the translations are bad, or that he just didn’t know or understand the West. Let it be said, those other American icons of Western storytelling, Zane Grey and James Fenimore Cooper, were no better then May in that regard, and had less of an excuse because they actually lived on this side of the pond. Grey was the better romantic though. My first and only walk with Zane Grey through the American West of his imagination, began on the first pages of Lone Star Ranger…
This is why Zane Grey became so popular, and why his American West came to define the real West for generations. That last little touch with the gambler placing an Ace of Spades over the bullet holes is great stuff. But it didn’t compare to Louis L’amour, and I put the book down and never picked it back up. Louis L’amour could paint a scary picture of a bad guy with just a few deft sentences of description, not all this face distorted and expressive of the most malignant intent, he was a wild and sinister figure crap. You got the feeling reading L’amour that you were really there to see it all, not that you were watching it on Saturday morning TV. May, at least in translation, writes a lot like Grey and Cooper, which is why I can’t read him. And his West, and Grey’s, and Cooper’s just isn’t real. But sometimes real isn’t what’s wanted. You want the myth. You want the high opera. You want to see the struggle between good and evil drawn out in sharp, bold strokes because that story Is more then the sum of its real life parts. Art, Picasso said, is a lie that makes us see the truth. One of these days I have to go see that Karl May festival for myself, and the German cowboys and German indians that gather there to pow-wow…
The Weather In Baltimore, For My Family Out In California Where They Don’t Have “Weather”… Looks like we’re finally going to get a good snowing in this season. The sidewalks and streets in my little Baltimore neighborhood were covered with the white powdery stuff this morning, but not very deep. It’s sticking though, and they’re calling for it to keep on coming down all day and into tomorrow, when for our wintery pleasure it will turn to freezing rain. Swell. The trick now is to not clean your car off as the snow falls, because when the freezing rain comes down on top of that it’ll be real easy to get the ice off. Just bang your hand on the sheet of ice on top of the snow and crack it apart. Then it’ll just slide off the snow, and off the car and you won’t have to scrape it off. Some years ago when I lived in Cockeysville, a helpful neighbor cleaned the snow off my car one afternoon when they were calling for a freezing rain that night. I wanted to throttle him, but I’m a wuss and I just planted a smile on my face and tried to explain to him that he’d just created a lot of ice scraping fun for both of us the next morning. Surprisingly, the look on his face when it dawned on him was not very satisfying. I got my winter hat in the mail, just in time for the snow. The rabbit fur ear liner is very nice…but it seems a tad big somehow. It fits fine and snug around my head but comes down really low to my brow. I don’t think a smaller size would fit around my head, but I’m not used to having a hat come down that far to my brow either. So maybe I mis-measured my head. The eternal problem with singleness: It’s hard to measure yourself. Inside and out. Which is why we need companionship. More for the inside then the outside, although having someone to take your measure on the outside can be handy from time to time too. It’s not good to be only seeing yourself inside of mirrors. You need to see yourself in another person’s smile every now and then too.
The You Can Marry Anyone Of The Opposite Sex You Want Argument I’ve considered this one a good test of mendacious jerk factor ever since I ran into a particularly loathsome creep on Usenet named Steve Fordyce, whose favorite hobby horse it was… The marriage laws do not discriminate against homosexuals. Now, everybody…including the bigots who make this argument by the way…know that this is a bogus argument. Let’s apply it to a different set of people… Laws that prohibit the practice of Judaism do The problem is it sounds perfectly logical. How can you argue that treating people the same is discrimination? But it’s a fallacy of ambiguity. To say that you are treating everyone the same is not to say you are treating everyone equitably. The trick here is that a word is being used in two different senses at the same time. Look at this again… The marriage laws do not discriminate against homosexuals. The problem is with the word ‘discriminate’. In this statement, it is being used in two difference senses at the same time. Let’s look at its definition. This one I took from The Free Dictionary…
So in the one sense, yes, the law makes no distinction between gay and straight. But it does not follow then, that the second sense of the word ‘discriminate’, to make a distinction against or in favor of a particular person or group is also not true. Let’s rephrase it… The marriage laws do not distinguish between homosexuals This statement is both true and much clearer now as to adverse discrimination, in the first sense of the word, that homosexuals endure even though they are not being discriminated in the second sense of the word. Let’s try it another way. The marriage laws treat homosexuals and heterosexuals Here the ambiguity is on the word ‘equally’. Once again, it is being used in two difference senses at the same time…
‘Equally’ is being used to mean both Having the same privileges, status, or rights: equal before the law and Impartial; just; equitable. But one does not necessarily follow from the other. Let’s rephrase it… The marriage laws treat homosexuals as if they were heterosexuals Now the problem is more clearly understood. The marriage laws deny that gay people even exist. The fallacy is one of equivocation. It is using a word in two different senses, to prove a conclusion that does not follow from the stated premise, simply because the same word appears in both the premise and the conclusion. A feather is light. See how that works? Now look at this… Marriage laws do not discriminate between homosexuals and heterosexuals. It simply does not follow. Yes, the law does not discriminate between gay and straight. It does not follow that the law does not discriminate against gay people. Nobody makes this argument honestly. Nobody. This is bad faith on its face. When you hear someone making this argument, you know you are dealing with either a bigot or an ass, and usually both.
|
Visit The Woodward Class of '72 Reunion Website For Fun And Memories, WoodwardClassOf72.com![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
|
|||
| |||||